Engineering tools beside a sealed mandate folder - Beyond Chiefs

Hiring a CTO or Tech Leader: When Executive Search Makes Sense

A headhunter makes sense for a technology leadership role when the position shapes the direction of the company, when only a small number of people have the right experience, or when the search has to stay confidential. For a CTO, a VP Engineering or a Head of Engineering in a growing company, at least one of these conditions usually applies. For team lead roles, your own recruiting is often enough.

Which tech leadership roles are we talking about?

Titles vary, but three levels are common. The Chief Technology Officer (CTO) sits on the management team and is responsible for technology as a whole: architecture, engineering, infrastructure and often the technical side of the product. The VP Engineering runs the engineering organisation day to day, with a focus on people, delivery and process. The Head of Engineering leads one area or several teams and reports to the CTO or VP.

Before a search starts, it helps to be clear about which of these roles the company actually needs. A business that asks for a CTO but needs someone to stabilise delivery is really looking for a VP Engineering.

When does executive search make sense?

Executive search means a consultancy approaches suitable leaders directly and in confidence instead of waiting for applications. It is worth the effort when:

  • the role belongs to the first or second management level,
  • the role is being created for the first time and its scope still needs to be defined,
  • the current leader is still in place and the search must not become public,
  • job postings have brought strong engineers but no one with leadership experience at the required scale,
  • investors or a supervisory board expect a structured, documented selection process.

It is usually not necessary for roles with a clear brief below the second level, where a good job posting and an internal recruiting team reach enough qualified people.

How does a tech executive search work?

A careful search follows five steps. First, the brief: what the person should achieve, which decisions they own and who they report to. Second, a market review to identify where people with relevant experience work. Third, a direct and discreet approach. Fourth, assessment through in-depth conversations and references taken with the candidate's consent. Fifth, a short list of well-argued candidates and support through to signing.

Serious firms work exclusively on a retained basis, meaning one firm carries responsibility for the search from start to finish.

What should you look for in candidates?

Technical depth is a requirement, not the deciding factor. What separates strong technology leaders is whether they have led an organisation of comparable size, how they explain trade-offs between speed, quality and cost, and how well they work with product, sales and finance. Experience with artificial intelligence is increasingly part of the brief. Whether that belongs with the CTO or in a separate role is covered in our article on the CTO with AI expertise.

Frequently asked questions

CTO or VP Engineering: which do we need?

If the main task is technology strategy and architecture, a CTO. If it is running and scaling the engineering teams, a VP Engineering. Larger companies have both.

Can we promote from within?

Yes, if someone has the leadership experience the next stage requires. Comparing an internal candidate with the external market makes the decision more robust.

Does the leader need experience in our industry?

Not necessarily. Experience with a similar scale and a similar type of change often matters more than sector knowledge.

Talk to us

Beyond Chiefs is an executive search boutique for technology and AI leadership roles in Germany, Austria and Switzerland. Read more about our AI executive search, or book a 30-minute conversation to discuss your situation.

Recent Blog Posts

Empty mortarboard with sealed AI executive mandate - Motto x Beyond Chiefs

Academic-to-AI-Executive: chair not automatic exec

Team Beyond Chiefs
Read More
Empty advisory chair with sealed NED AI accountability folder - Motto x Beyond Chiefs

Advisory board / NED and AI: advisory demands a bearer - not a supervisory clone

Team Beyond Chiefs
Read More
Two organ seats advisory and supervisory with sealed AI bearer cut - Motto x Beyond Chiefs

Advisory vs supervisory board and AI: two organs, one bearer cut

Team Beyond Chiefs
Read More
Empty post-signature seal after the CAIO signs - Motto x Beyond Chiefs

After the CAIO Signs

Team Beyond Chiefs
Read More

CONTACT Us

Leading the Future with AI-Driven Leadership

contact us
.bc-ask-ai__links a{align-items:center;border:1px solid rgba(255,255,255,.5);border-radius:7px;box-sizing:border-box;color:#fff;display:inline-flex;font-size:17px;justify-content:center;min-height:44px;min-width:150px;padding:8px 16px;text-decoration:none} .bc-ask-ai__links a:hover{background:rgba(255,255,255,.14);color:#fff} .bc-ask-ai__links a:focus-visible{outline:3px solid #bfaaff;outline-offset:3px} @media(max-width:479px){.bc-ask-ai{margin-top:32px;padding-top:24px}.bc-ask-ai__links{display:grid}.bc-ask-ai__links a{width:100%}}